What is a citizen?

In the age of open borders and supranational governance, citizenship is either a transactional status or a taboo subject. But who belongs where – and why – remains a live question.

In this Battle of Ideas satellite event, novelist and writer Dolan Cummings examines the meaning of citizenship: is it a legal label, a shared fate, or a political responsibility?

In a piece on his Substack L’esprit de l’escalier Dolan challenged contemporary ideas of citizenship:

‘Our citizenship is comprised of interweaving strands: common heritage, common rights and responsibilities and common beliefs. The weight given to each varies over time and between places. But if there is such a thing as universal humanity – and I think there is – it emerges not from biology or from abstract ideas, but from participation in civilised life, which means being a citizen of a particular polis.’

At a time when some are seeking to reassert British citizenship by waving the flag and protesting against open borders, while others prefer Palestinian flags and cosmopolitan identities, does anything unite us as citizens?

Speaker: Dolan Cummings

Dolan is an Associate of the Academy of Ideas, a novelist and writer. His latest novel is The Pictish Princess…and other stories from before there was a Scotland.

Chair: Ruth Mieschbuehler

Ruth Mieschbuehler is programme leader for Education Studies at the University of Derby. She is Swiss citizen and a new British subject. Ruth convenes the Derby AFAF Branch.

Date, Time and Venue: Thursday 13 November at 19.00 in the Brunswick Inn, Derby

Tickets £3 plus fee on Eventbrite.

What is a citizen?

Our next Salon, powered by Zoom, will be held on Thursday 4 June at 7 PM.

Mladen Pupavac and Vanessa Pupavac from the Centre for the Study of Social and Global Justice, University of Nottingham and co-authors of the forthcoming book Changing European Visions of Disaster and Development will lead our discussion of ‘What is a citizen?’.

“The idea of being a citizen is tied to membership of a city or state, that is, rights, freedom and responsibilities derived from membership of a particular place. 

Crucially as citizens we enjoy rights of political self-determination where the city or state lies. 

In the modern era our core rights have been organised around being a citizen. The French Revolution put the citizens and the rights of man at its heart. However, the French philosopher Jean Jacques Rousseau had recognised a tension between the claiming the rights of man and having to being a citizen. 

Some human rights advocates argue that we should move away from many of the distinctions between citizens and non-citizens, and ground more rights on universal human rights. What would we gain or lose were we to do so? 

Thinking about this universal idea may help us determine what it is significant about being a citizen.” 

This Salon is free but please register by emailing profdennishayes@aol.com and you will be sent an Agenda and a link to join the event.

(Illustration: Déclaration des droits de l’homme et du citoyen, by Le Barbier (1789) Public Domain)